https://www.bintheredumpthatusa.com/thumb/750~img/blog/bagster-dumpster-rental-new.jpg~Dumpster Vs. Bagster®" alt="Dumpster Vs. Bagster®Dumpster Vs. Bagster®
Dumpster rental

WM Bagster® vs Dumpster Rental | Bagster® Alternatives | Bin There Dump That

 (modified Sep 21, 2022)

Paper or plastic? Dogs or cats? The correct answers depend on what you need, want or prefer.

Similarly, dumpster rentals and the WM Bagster® also have their own sets of pros and cons. So before you use one or the other, make sure to do your homework to see which one is best for you and your project.

Here are five things to consider when it comes to choosing between Waste Management's (WM) Bagster® and the Bagster® alternative of a dumpster rental from a local provider like Bin There Dump That.


Container Size And Materials Accepted

2 Bagsters Placed In Bin There Dump That Truck

The main determining factor for you might be what you can fit in the WM Bagster® or an alternative like a dumpster

Dumpsters come in a variety of sizes from 4- to 40-yard bins and hold both small and large items, including mattresses, boxes, furniture, landscape and home renovation materials, appliances, clothes, trash and clutter. You can talk with the dumpster operator to see which size they would recommend for your project.

The WM Bagster® is designed to handle smaller jobs like garage, attic or yard cleanouts and is 2 1/2 feet high, 4 feet wide and 8 feet long. It has a 3-cubic-yard capacity and can hold up to 3,300 pounds of debris or waste. The Bagster® is available in one size.

They both do not accept hazardous materials.

6 Yard Dumpster Rental Quote, Get Your Free Quote

Durability of These Waste Disposal Commodities

While both can help you clear your home of clutter and unwanted items, they have different levels of durability.

The WM Bagster® is a tarp-like material with handles. When you put items in the bag, you'll need to start filling it at the edges to help the bag keep its rectangular shape. You should also lay items down flat and not pile debris above the edges.

A dumpster is heavy-duty, allowing you to throw or carry items into the bin. So there's no need to lay items flat, as the dumpster is a hard metal and won't lose its shape.

Roll Off Dumpster Rental Cost vs Bagster® Cost

Across the country, typically, the cost of a Bagster® is $30. However, like the delivery and pick up of a roll off dumpster rental, the price of pickup charges for the Bagster® will vary throughout the country.

For the pick up of the Bagster®, you should approximate that cost at around $160. For an average, all-in cost of the Bagster® waste disposal methodr, you should budget around $225.

In contrast, if you're looking for comparable capacity of the Bagster® in a roll off dumpster, it would be a 4 yard dumpster. This container will comfortably hold a Bagster® and its contents. The cost of a 4 yard bin with Bin There Dump That will range from $200-$400 depending on where you live.

Roll Off Dumpster Rental Cost vs Bagster Cost

The average National cost of a Bagster is $30. It’s always a good idea to double check your local costs though, as prices do vary depending on the region much like they do when you rent a dumpster. While that may seem like a great price for an easy solution to your waste removal needs it does not include the price of removal and disposal at your local landfill.

Once you’ve loaded your Bagster up with waste you then have to call and arrange a removal. Just like the initial rental fee, the cost of removal can vary slightly. At current rates, you’re looking at paying around $200 extra for the pick up from your driveway.

So if you’re thinking about renting a Bagster for a project, you’ll want to consider more than just the initial cost — you’ll want to look at the whole picture. The full cost of renting a Bagster, having it picked up, removed and dumped at the local Landfill is between $225 and $250 depending on your location.

Why a Dumpster May Be a Better Solution for Waste Removal than the Bagster

A Bagster isn’t the only option for small waste removal projects if you want the convenience of picking up at your home. You might also want to consider renting a small dumpster.

How does the Bagster’s Capacity compare to a roll off dumpster’s capacity? Well, the smallest dumpster you can usually rent from your nearest supplier is going to be a 4-yard bin and it will actually fit more material than a Bagster which only holds about 3-yards of material.

If you’re worried about the Bagster fitting all of your waste, a dumpster rental is a great alternative that will give you the extra space you need. The price is comparable as well. How much is it to rent a dumpster? Depending on where you live, a 4-yard dumpster rental from Bin There Dump That will cost between $225 and $400.

In most cases, it’s closer to that $225 mark and that includes your removal. For a similar price, you have an extra yard to work with and that can save you the frustration of wondering if everything will fit.

Placement Options

Waste Management Dumpster Truck
You can put dumpsters and the Bagster® on your driveway or yard (with some exceptions). If you want to put them on the street, you'll need to check with the city and ask about local regulations.

You can have the dumpster operator leave the rental in a convenient location on your property. Just avoid putting it on sloped surfaces, a neighbor's yard or soft ground. The operator will put boards under the bin to keep it from damaging your yard or driveway.

Since the Bagster® is picked up by a crane on the WM truck, there are some placement requirements. The bag must be 5 feet away from structures or vehicles, have at least 18 feet of vertical clearance and be clear of overhead wires, trees or structures. You should also avoid putting it on sloped surfaces.

Because the tri-axle vehicle used to pick up the Bagster® at your home doesn't navigate residential areas too well, it's essential you place your Bagster® as close to the curb as possible. This will save you a headache later when a provider comes by to pick up your Bagster® and you're told it's not close enough to the curb. You'll then be stuck unloading and reloading.

The Bagster® alternative of a Bin There Dump That dumpster rental can be placed essentially wherever you'd like it on your property.

6 Yard Dumpster Rental Quote, Get Your Free Quote

Turnaround Time

Another difference between the two disposal methods is the pickup schedule.

With a roll-off dumpster rental, you can call your local Dumpster Consultant to schedule an exact date and time for the operator to pick up the bin. You don't have to be home when they come.

Waste Management will pick the Bagster® up within three business days from when you call to schedule the pickup. Their collections are made Monday to Friday from 5 a.m. to 8 p.m.

Bottom Line

Bagster Being Placed Into Bin There Dump That Dump
You need to know what your project will require — from the amount of material you'll have to how quickly you want it picked up — before deciding between the Bagster® or a Bagster® alternative like a roll off dumpster rental.

If you don't have much to throw out and you plan to work on the project for an extended or an unknown amount of time, the Bagster® might be the best choice since the price is the same no matter how long you keep it (you pay for the Bagster® and then for its pickup).

On the other hand, if you have a lot of items to dispose of and want a set pickup date, you'll need a dumpster to hold all of the materials. You also won't have to worry about not being able to fit all of your items in the bin if you end up with more than first expected.

If you decide a dumpster rental makes the most sense for your next project, contact your local franchise operator, and they'll get everything set up for you.

Download Free Guide on Renting a Dumpster

Images: Bagster in dumpster, WM truck

Related Blog Posts

What To Do With Old Tires? Here's 5 Useful Things You Should Know

We know how good it feels to get rid of unwanted junk around the house. But…

Read Article

Do I Need to Rent a Dumpster? Our Customers Rent Bins For These Home Projects

Bin There Dump That has helped homeowners across America with a reliable and…

Read Article

Dumpster Rental Vs. Junk Removal: What’s Right For You?

It seems there is no end to human ingenuity and entrepreneurialism. We’re…

Read Article

Should I Rent a Dumpster or Haul Trash to the Landfill Myself?

Have a lot of trash to remove from your property after a big project or cleanout?…

Read Article
Back to Blog List

Book your Residential Friendly Dumpster today!

Friendly, professional customer service, plus fair pricing, equals value.